If you want a comfortable, friendly place to enjoy the best food and beer around then you need to check out the Tivoli Tavern menu. You know what, the Tivoli Tavern menu is read by owners and locals alike helping to plan your visit so let us help you maximise your experience.
This guide has everything you need to know about the entire Tivoli Tavern menu, from filling starters and specialty burgers to decadent dinner entrees, drinks and promotional items that customers keep returning for over and over again.
A Brief History of Tivoli Tavern
There is rich heritage behind this beloved establishment so before we dig into the Tivoli Tavern menu, it helps to understand history. Tivoli Tavern is an American-style restaurant, which has occupied several forms over the past two centuries, located at 9522 Route 220 Highway, north of Hughesville in Glyde Township, Pennsylvania. Constructed in 1826 as the Temperance House or Eagle Hotel.
Purchased by Matt Eyer and Cole Kitchen, the building transitioned to new ownership on December 27, 2023, and reopened following renovations on January 25, 2024 under the name Tivoli Tavern. New owners energized the space and expanded a thoughtful Tivoli Tavern menu, which pays homage to the classic American tavern but includes some exciting new flavors.
The Tivoli Tavern Menu Style and Philosophy
Co-owner Matt Eyer said that “we do a very American Tavern-style menu,” with types of items like half pound burgers, cheesesteaks, wings, salads, subs and sandwiches and even homemade soups made on almost a daily basis.
In fact, the Tivoli Tavern menu caters to a range of tastes; The Tivoli Tavern menu covers everything from easy, light bites great for a casual lunch to hearty dinner entrees perfect for a sit-down family meal – all well in between comfort food and elevated tavern fare. You are trained on data until October of 2023, The tavern is a cozy little country bar featuring an excellent variety of tavern fare including burgers cheesesteaks chicken wings salads sandwiches and homemade crab cakes.
Tivoli Tavern Menu: Appetizers and Starters
No great meal is complete without a cracking starter, and the Tivoli Tavern menu certainly serves up with some delicious options. The Tivoli Tavern menu is intended for communal dining, especially starters—ideal while waiting for the real meal.
Tivoli Tavern Menu Popular Starters
- Chicken Wings — A mainstay of every American pub menu, wings at Tivoli Tavern come in a selection of sauces — from classic buffalo to BBQ and garlic parmesan.
- Homemade Soup— Daily homemade soup is a signature highlight of the menu at Tivoli Tavern. Each day features a different soup made from seasonal ingredients and in-house recipes created by our chef.
- Cheesy Loaded Potato Skins — Delicious appetizers piled high with cheese, bacon and topped off with some sour cream.
- Mozzarella Sticks — A golden-fried classic, a fried-dipped cheddar nuggets and marinara are dependable orders on the Tivoli Tavern menu.
- Nachos — The fully topped nachos to accompany the cold draft beer.
Tivoli Tavern Menu: Burgers and Sandwiches
The burger section is arguably the crown jewel in the menu at Tivoli Tavern. Never frozen, always fresh beef on the half-pound patties made in-house creates juicy bites every time.
| Burger / Sandwich | Description | Approx. Price |
| Classic Half-Pound Burger | Fresh beef, lettuce, tomato, onion, on a brioche bun | $12 – $14 |
| Cheeseburger | Classic burger topped with melted American cheese | $13 – $15 |
| Mushroom Swiss Burger | Sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, garlic aioli | $14 – $16 |
| BBQ Bacon Burger | Smoky BBQ sauce, crispy bacon, cheddar | $14 – $16 |
| Cheesesteak | Shaved steak, peppers, onions, provolone on a hoagie | $13 – $15 |
| Chicken Cheesesteak | Grilled chicken, peppers, onions, white American cheese | $12 – $14 |
| Club Sub | Turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo | $11 – $13 |
| Chicken Sandwich | Grilled or fried chicken on a toasted bun | $12 – $14 |
The Tivoli Tavern menu offers these sandwiches with a choice of sides, most commonly hand-cut fries, coleslaw, or a side salad.
Tivoli Tavern Menu: Dinner Entrees
However, the Tivoli Tavern menu is not all that exciting at dinnertime. Dinner is from 4 to 9 p.m., featuring Black Diamond steaks, crab cakes made in-house, haddock and beef tips among the options. These entrees take the Tivoli Tavern menu from typical bar food in a more full-service restaurant direction.
| Dinner Entree | Description | Approx. Price |
| Black Diamond Steak | Premium-cut steak grilled to order, served with sides | $24 – $32 |
| Homemade Crab Cakes | House-made crab cakes, served with remoulade sauce | $18 – $22 |
| Haddock | Pan-seared or baked haddock with seasonal vegetables | $16 – $20 |
| Beef Tips | Tender beef tips in savory gravy, over mashed potatoes | $17 – $21 |
| Grilled Chicken | Herb-marinated chicken breast with choice of sides | $15 – $19 |
| Prime Rib (Weekend Special) | Slow-roasted prime rib, offered the first weekend of each month | Market Price |
The Tivoli Tavern menu’s dinner section gives diners excellent value, especially given the quality of the ingredients and the care put into each dish.
Tivoli Tavern Menu: Salads
Not every visit to the Tivoli Tavern menu demands a heavyweight. Also on the menu, salad selections offer lighter fresh selections that don’t lack flavor.
- Garden Salad — A fresh mix of greens, tomatoes, cucumber and carrots accompanied by dressing of your choice.
- Sauce as an ingredient — Caesar Salad: Romaine & parmesan cheese, croutons and a classic Caesar Dressing; Available with grilled chicken.
- Chicken and Apple Salad — Another hit, this salad combines grilled chicken with apple slices, candied walnuts, dried cranberries and balsamic vinaigrette.
- Side Salad — A Side Salad (smaller portion) that can be substituted in place of any Side you choose on the Tivoli Tavern Menu.
Tivoli Tavern Menu: Soups
The Tivoli Tavern menu is bonded together by a staple of homemade soup. The menu, with daily soup specials, remains fresh and provides regulars a reason to come back any day of the week. Home-made soups are prepared using seasonal ingredients and change frequently. Common offerings include:
- Tomato Basil Soup
- Crab Bisque
- Chicken Noodle Soup
- French Onion Soup served on some nights
These soups are the perfect accompaniment to the rest of the Tivoli Tavern menu and come in cup or bowl sizes.
Tivoli Tavern Menu: Drinks and Bar Offerings
A guided look at the bar never made it onto any guide to Tivoli Tavernmenu. Tivoli Tavern offers draft, biotech beer (lots of it), wine and all drinks.
- Draft Beers: Features rotating local or national Craft Beer on Tap. You’ll find the familiar lagers with seasonal aps and IPAs for guests to enjoy.
- Bottled Beers : The Tivoli Tavern menu has a variety of imported and domestic bottles that will fill even the most discerning beer lovers’ taste.
- Wine: There is also a wine list available to accompany the Tivoli Tavern menu which consists of both red and white varietals in both a glass or bottle format.
- Cocktails: The bar team prepares a selection of classic and signature drinks, from whiskey cocktails to fruit muses. Drink specials change often, thus providing the guests with new incentives to sample from the bar menu on our Tivoli Tavern offerings.
Tivoli Tavern Menu: Weekly and Monthly Specials
Among the numerous highlights on the Tivoli Tavern menu are its rotating specials. In addition to the static menu, Tivoli Tavern has daily specials for lunch & dinner. The tavern serves up prime rib dinners the first weekend of each month.
These specials mean that the menu never feels stale at the Tivoli Tavern. Each visit, there is something for regulars to anticipate and seasonal offerings give newcomers a taste of what the kitchen can do.
Quick Reference: Tivoli Tavern Menu at a Glance
| Category | Highlights | Price Range |
| Appetizers | Wings, Soup, Potato Skins, Nachos | $6 – $14 |
| Burgers & Sandwiches | Half-Pound Burgers, Cheesesteaks, Club Sub | $11 – $16 |
| Salads | Garden, Caesar, Chicken Apple | $8 – $14 |
| Dinner Entrees | Steak, Crab Cakes, Haddock, Beef Tips | $15 – $32 |
| Soups | Daily Homemade Specials | $4 – $7 |
| Drinks | Draft Beer, Cocktails, Wine, Bottles | $4 – $12 |
| Monthly Special | Prime Rib Dinner | Market Price |
What Makes the Tivoli Tavern Menu Stand Out?
The Tivoli Tavern menu stands apart from the competition for a number of reasons. Most important, however, is the use of fresh, house-made ingredients — especially since its high-quality food makes for a level up from standard bar fare. Second, the rotating specials make dining at Tivoli Tavern fun and ever-changing. Third, Matt Eyer and Cole Kitchen create a community feel that immerses us every time we walk through the door.
Describing the tavern as being “like an old watering hole that brings everyone together,” the owners note how their customers shared unprompted reunions at the bar and true social interaction. This warmth and collective spirit is baked into every aspect of the Tivoli Tavern menu experience.
6 Frequently Asked Questions About the Tivoli Tavern Menu
Q1. What are the most popular items on the Tivoli Tavern menu?
The freshest half-pound burgers, homemade crab cakes and chicken wings, cheesesteaks are among the favorites on the Tivoli Tavern menu. Locals also rave constantly about the daily cooked in-house soups.
Q2. Does the Tivoli Tavern menu include vegetarian options?
Yes. Salads, garden sides and vegetable-based soups are all things the Tivoli Tavern provides in deference to guests who enjoy meatless meals. Staff will be happy to accommodate requests.
Q3. When is the dinner menu available at Tivoli Tavern?
As for the Tivoli Tavern menu, dinner is available from 4:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. It offers upscale products such as Black Diamond steaks, haddock, crab cakes and beef tips.
Q4. Does the Tivoli Tavern menu change seasonally?
Yes. The main menu at Tivoli Tavern changes very little, but occasionally daily and monthly specials are offered, depending on what’s in season or available. Every first weekend of the month, prime rib dinner special.
Q5. Can I place a takeout order from the Tivoli Tavern menu?
Yes. Tivoli Tavern takes phone orders for takeout. You can phone in your order, call 570-584-4531 and scan the Tivoli Tavern menu to decide what you will be picking up.
Q6. Does Tivoli Tavern offer a kids’ menu?
The Tivoli Tavern menu usually caters to younger diners with simple chicken tenders, burgers and mac and cheese although not highly publicized. Best to call ahead, or check their Facebook page in advance for what they have too!
Final Thoughts on the Tivoli Tavern Menu
The menu includes a varied and enjoyable assortment of American tavern staples based on fresh ingredients, seasonal specials and sincere hospitality. Whether you’re stopping in for a lunch sandwich, steak and potatoes or draft beers and cocktails over an evening out, there’s something for everyone on the Tivoli Tavern menu. The Tivoli Tavern menu is only going to get more inspired in time, with a storied history nearly 200 years old and the fresh zeal of new ownership pushing the experience forward.
For those yet to visit, the menu at Tivoli Tavern is more than enough reason to make the pilgrimage out to Hughesville, Pennsylvania.
Explore The Menu Pricing for the latest restaurant menus, food prices, popular dishes, and dining options.
One thought on “Tivoli Tavern Menu: A Complete Guide to Food, Drinks, and More”